Buildings in the Middle East depicting economic diversity

Beyond commodities – how the Middle East markets are diversifying by investing in new sectors

As Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries strive to diversify their economies away from oil, Capital Markets have become unexpectedly valuable partners.

The GCC is looking to make sectors like tech and renewable energy the new oil, as it makes finding new private sector sources of wealth and employment an urgent priority.

Eyeing the volatility of oil prices and seeking to reduce youth unemployment, the GCC is seeking to improve economic diversity and rebalance economies away from hydrocarbons and the public sector. The International Monetary Fund estimates that 27 million youths will enter the region’s labour market over the next five years, with 60 per cent of the population aged under 301. Governments are introducing incentives and reforms to boost the growth of private companies from sectors such as technology, renewable energy, tourism and areas related to oil like petrochemicals, focusing for instance on support for small and medium-sized enterprises.

Saudi Arabia and the UAE are leading the drive to diversify economies. Both countries have introduced modernisation programmes, notably Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 that aimed to raise the private sector’s contribution to GDP from 40 per cent to 65 per cent by 20302. There have also been specific initiatives such as the March 2019 announcement by Abu Dhabi’s Mubadala sovereign wealth fund of Hub 713, a tech hub partnership with SoftBank intended to attract some of the world’s most valuable start-ups.

Saudi Aramco’s USD12 billion bond issue in April showed that in the capital markets at least, transformation is working. The order book attracted USD100 billion of demand, a new record for emerging markets4. Further, investors were reportedly drawn towards the parts of the deal with longest maturities, seizing the chance to buy 20- and 30-year bonds at relatively high yields. The bond issue’s success has helped to open the way for the company’s IPO, planned for 2020 to 20215.

Supportive capital markets

When oil prices started to fall in 2014, going from over USD100 a barrel to lows of below USD40 in 20166, this economic cloud had a silver lining. Facing escalating fiscal deficits7, the Gulf region’s oil-exporting governments started to tap capital markets to balance the books, with the result that they now have the capacity to help fund economic diversification.

In the past five years, the size of the region’s Capital Markets has almost tripled. Aside from the quantity of issuance, the market’s quality is also developing at a fast pace as it broadens out beyond just sovereigns and secondary market liquidity improves. In a market dominated by sovereign issuers, financial institutions are also issuing more and the groundwork is ready for corporates to follow.

While 2014 saw USD38.8 billion of issuance in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA), by 2018 that had increased to USD107.4 billion8. In just the first seven months or so of 2019, issuance stood at approximately USD74 billion. Based on our estimates, overall issuance is now expected to moderate in 2020 as sovereign issuance slows, however an uptick in new issue supply from financial institutions is expected to take up some of the slack.

Table of Figure 1. MENA Issuance (2014-2019YTD)

Figure 1. MENA Issuance (2014-2019YTD)

2019 is an important year for MENA bond markets. From January, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain and Kuwait were included in JP Morgan’s emerging market bond indexes for the first time, in recognition of the fact that the countries have issued a sizeable amount of the debt sold by emerging market countries in recent years9. This could bring some USD40 billion in flows over the next year or so, according to market analysts10, helping to temporarily keep a lid on borrowing costs.

Funding corporates

While sovereign borrowers have dominated the growth in issuance, the region’s banks have also become more prolific, more than doubling issuance from USD16.0 billion in 2014 to USD39.7 billion in 2018 (Figure 1). We have also seen one of the leading banks from the region issue the first green bond, the proceeds of which were used to fund sustainable finance projects in the United Arab Emirates. Corporates, however, have lagged behind with volumes peaking just over USD17.0 billion in 2018, scarcely above 2014’s level of USD16.7 billion (Figure 1).

Even so, we have seen a sharp rise in corporate issuance this year with volumes already approaching USD18.0 billion (Figure 1) and a number of corporate issuers expected to access the market before the end of the year. The success of the Saudi Aramco offer illustrates the strength of latent demand for the right corporate. With infrastructure finance loans growing, some of them related to Chinese “belt and road” projects, it is likely that the project companies will seek to tap the bond markets a few years from now in order to refinance their project loans.

There is scope for bond issuance from large real estate companies, independent regional hotel companies and even government-related entities.

But the MENA capital markets have some way to go before they efficiently finance private companies. For example, the region lacks a high-yield bond market, but this might now be a possibility as many fixed income investors now hold MENA bonds, and so have an appetite for relative value plays.

The next step

There is certainly growing interest and comfort among investors. Anecdotally, more than 50 international investors joined Standard Chartered’s annual investor trip to the Gulf in 2019, up from 20-30 in previous years. They are learning to understand and become comfortable with the region’s geopolitics and witnessing the improvements in financial disclosure and corporate governance, which extends from sovereigns to banks and corporates.

After five years of spectacular growth, as evidenced by the upsurge in issuance referred to above, MENA’s bond markets are now established. They have helped the region’s governments to fund diversification programmes and are increasingly helping to fund local banks, which in turn lend to local companies.

If corporate issuance now starts to grow, then capital markets will fund the private sector more directly, helping businesses from a range of sectors to decrease the region’s reliance on the public sector and oil.

Financial Times, Middle East jobs crisis risks fuelling unrest, IMF warns, July 12, 2018, paragraph 6

Arab News, Pace of Saudi Arabia’s private sector sell-off accelerates, April 2018, paragraph 3

Financial Times, Mubadala sets up tech hub in Abu Dhabi with SoftBank, March 2019, paragraph 7

4 Financial Times, Orders for first Saudi Aramco bond smash $100bn, April 9, 2019, paragraphs 1, 2

5 Aramco IPO on track for 2020-2021, says Saudi crown price. The National. June 16, 2019, paragraph 1

6 Macrotrends, WTI Crude Oil Prices - 10 Year Daily Chart, graph shows daily oil prices

7 Why Gulf economies struggle to wean themselves off oil. Economist. June 21, 2018, paragraphs 3,5

8 Source: Bloomberg MENA Issuance (see Figure 1).

9 Saudi Arabia, four other Gulf states to enter key JP Morgan bond indices. Reuters. September 26, 2018, paragraph 3

10 IMF, Regional Economic Update. Middle East, North Africa, Afghanistan and Pakistan. April 2019, page 9 paragraph 4

This article was also published by Euromoney.

Back to news and views